哲学社会科学版
陕西师范大学学报(哲学社会科学版)
中国古代史研究
中国古代引礼入法的得与失
PDF下载 ()
赵 世 超
(陕西师范大学 历史文化学院, 陕西 西安 710062)
赵世超,男,河南南阳人,历史学博士,陕西师范大学历史文化学院教授,博士生导师。
摘要:
中国古代的成文法起自军法。其长处是公平、公开和确定不移,其短处是过于苛暴。优缺点出自一源,即战争环境的需要。儒家引礼入法的目的在于矫秦之失,但由于设置双重标准,最终必然会走上以礼代法和以礼坏法的道路,从而使中国古代始终处在有法律而无法治的人治阶段。要建设法治社会,必须以开放的心态学习世界各国的成功经验。过分夸大引礼入法的作用和意义,曲折表达了对法律等级性的肯定。人人都承认法治优于人治,但人人都不愿自觉接受法律的约束,并对司法特权充满依恋,是中国法治建设所面临的最大难题。
关键词:
中国法制; 引礼入法; 以礼代法; 以礼坏法; 司法特权
收稿日期:
2010-09-19
中图分类号:
K203; D904
文献标识码:
A
文章编号:
1672-4283(2011)01-0005-25
基金项目:
Doi:
Gains and Pains from Introduction Etiquette into Law in Ancient China
ZHAO Shichao
(College of History and Civilization, Shaanxi Normal University, Xi’an 710062, Shaanxi)
Abstract:
Statute law of ancient China was derived from martial law. Its advantages lay in fairness, openness and firmness and its disadvantages in harshness and brutality. All its advantages and disadvantages arose from the same reason, that is, the need of war context. To correct the defects of the Qin Dynasty, Confucians introduced etiquette into law, which led to malpractices of substituting etiquette for law or abusing law by means of etiquette, however, owing to the double standards. As a result, China in ancient times always remained at the stage of rule by man, in which law failed to result in government by law. In order to build a lawgoverning society, we must learn successful experience from other countries in the world with an open mind. An overexaggeration of the significance of introducing etiquette into law means a tortuous show of affirming the hierarchy of law. Therefore the greatest trouble facing construction of government by law in China is that, albeit admitting the superiority of government by law over government by man, no one is willing to bound by law by attaching closely to judicial priviledges.
KeyWords:
government by law in China; introduction of etiquette into law; substituting etiquette for law; abusing law by means of etiquette; judicial priviledge