哲学社会科学版
陕西师范大学学报(哲学社会科学版)
周秦汉唐文化研究
以武事比文艺——杜甫及中晚唐诗人的一种论文方式
PDF下载 ()
刘 青 海
(北京语言大学 中华文化研究院, 北京 100083)
刘青海,女,湖南华容人,文学博士,北京语言大学中华文化研究院教授。
摘要:
以武事比文艺,源于汉人“射策”之说。杜甫加以巨大的发展,成为他创作诗歌意象、阐述诗歌艺术精妙之理的独特方式,对后人影响很大。杜甫诗论中的以武事比文艺,根据喻体的不同,可分为骑射和战阵两类。骑射方面,杜诗或以“破的”比喻创作之得法,以“飞动”传达以雄健为尚的审美倾向,或将“射策”等陈词化作“穿杨”的生动形象,对中晚唐诗人产生普遍影响。战阵方面,杜诗多用“战胜”“笔阵”“劘垒”“先锋”“铦锋”等,表现出挑战古人的自信和追求雄健风格的倾向。中唐元白、韩愈、刘禹锡乃至晚唐陆龟蒙等人于唱酬之际,于杜甫以战阵喻诗尤多取法。但中晚唐诗人更关注喻体(战阵)本身,不断地丰富细节,融入典实,加以戏剧化描写,却鲜有对诗艺本身的阐发。这和杜甫很不一样,体现出中晚唐诗人学杜的局限,以及普遍的争胜意识和流派门户观念对于诗人创作实践的复杂影响。
关键词:
唐代诗歌; 杜甫; 以诗论诗; 元白; 唱和
收稿日期:
2020-09-03
中图分类号:
I207.22
文献标识码:
A
文章编号:
1672-4283(2021)01-0085-12
基金项目:
教育部哲学社会科学研究重大课题攻关项目“中华诗词的语言艺术原理及其历史生成机制研究”(18JZD021)
Doi:
Compare Literary Arts to Military Affairs: A Way of Comment on Literature by Du Fu and the Poets in the Middle and Late Tang Dynasty
LU Qinghai
(Chinese Culture Research Institute, Beijing Language and Culture University, Beijing 100083)
Abstract:
The way to compare literary arts to military affairs originates from shece(射策,a civil official examination compared to shooting an arrow) in the Han Dynasty. Du Fu developed it into a particular way to create poetic images and explained on poetic theory which affected the later ages. According to the different vehicles, it may be divided into two kinds: one is riding and shooting, and the other is a battle. With regard to the former, Du Fu likened writing in the proper way to podi (破的,hit the target), expressing his aesthetic tendency of pursuing strength by feidong(飞动,the state of the arrow rustling in the air), and converting the cliche like shece(射策) into such lively images like chuanyang(穿杨,shoot a polar leaf in the distance). With the latter, Du Fu used zhanshen(战胜,to defeat),bizhen(笔阵,arrangements in writing compared to military planning),milei(靡垒,to approach siege works),xianfeng(先锋,vangard) and xianfeng(铦锋,a sharp cutting edge) to express his selfconfidence to challenge the ancients and to pursue a robust style, which was adopted by Yuanzhen, Bai Juyi, Han Yu and Liu Yuxi in the middle Tang and Lu Guimeng in the Late Tang, especially when they composed verses in correspondence with each other. While the poets in the middle and late Tang Dynasty mentioned above attached more importance to the vehicle(battle) itself with rich details, literary quotations, and dramatic descriptions, these was not much discussion of the art of poetry itself, which was different from that of Du Fu. Such difference shows the limitation of the poets’learning from Du Fu, and the complicated influence of popular competitive and factionalism on poem writing.
KeyWords:
Tang Poems; Du Fu; to comment on poetry in a poem; Yuan Zhen and Bai Juyi; to compose verses in correspondence with somebody