哲学社会科学版
陕西师范大学学报(哲学社会科学版)
哲学研究
万物本原与人生价值:论张载儒佛之辨的核心问题
PDF下载 ()
江 求 流
(陕西师范大学 哲学与政府管理学院, 陕西 西安 710119)
江求流,男,安徽寿县人,哲学博士,陕西师范大学哲学与政府管理学院讲师。
摘要:
儒佛之辨构成了张载哲学的重要内容,而对万物本原的追问与对人生价值的安顿则是其中的两个核心问题。就前者而言,佛教主张“真如缘起”,以真如本心为万物的本原,但在张载看来,这一思想实质上是以精神实体作为万物的本原,不具有真理性。因此张载重新肯定了儒家以气为万物本原的思想,并对其真理性进行了论证;就后一问题而言,佛教以“涅槃寂灭”为人生价值安顿的根本方式,并以“真如缘起”思想为人生价值的理论基础。在张载看来,既然真如缘起思想不具有真理性,这种价值安顿方式的理论基础也就难以成立。张载进一步批判了“涅槃寂灭”思想的消极无为及其产生的消极影响,并基于气化流行的生命共同体思想,对“存顺没宁”这一儒家式人生价值安顿方式进行了阐发。
关键词:
张载; 儒佛之辨; 万物本原; 人生价值
收稿日期:
2020-07-10
中图分类号:
B244.4
文献标识码:
A
文章编号:
1672-4283(2020)05-0137-08
基金项目:
国家哲学社会科学基金项目“宋代理学的佛教批判及其现代意义研究”(17XZX012)
Doi:
The Origin of All Beings and the Value of Human Life: On the Key Points in Zhang Zai’s Research on the Difference Between Confucianism and Buddhism
JIANG Qiuliu
(School of Philosophy and Government, Shaanxi Normal University,Xi’an 710119, Shaanxi)
Abstract:
Distinguishing between Confucianism and Buddhism is a very important topic in Zhang Zai’s philosophy, and questioning the origin of all beings and setting down the value of human life are the two key points.As far as the former is concerned, Buddhism advocates that “Tathagata”(真如) is the origin of all beings,but in Buddhism,Tathagata is a spirit entity, so this view is not compatible to the reason of human beings nowadays.According to Zhang Zai’s Confucian view, every being originates from Qi(气), and he defends his view by way of reasoning; As to the latter point, Buddhism advocates that the true value of human life is to achieve “Nirvana”(涅槃),however, as Zhang Zai pointed out, this view is based on the view that“Tathagata”(真如) os the origin of all beings.If the former is wrong, therefore, the latter is also untrustable.Zhang Zai criticized the negative characteristics of Nirvana and its negative influence of participation, and elucidated the Confucian view of the value of human life, based it on the view that every being originates from Qi(气).
KeyWords:
Zhang Zai; the distinguishing between Confucianism and Buddhism; the origin of all beings; the value of human life