哲学社会科学版
陕西师范大学学报(哲学社会科学版)
中国古代哲学研究
仁性和智性在道德存有中的不同作用
PDF下载 ()
杨 泽 波
(复旦大学 哲学学院, 上海 200433)
杨泽波,男,河北石家庄人,哲学博士,复旦大学哲学学院教授,博士研究生导师。
摘要:
道德存有是儒家学理的重要内容,也是牟宗三受教于熊十力后一生特别关注的话题。但受理性、感性两分法的局限,他的阐发尚有一些不足。如果将这个思想置于儒家生生伦理学智性、仁性、欲性三分法的框架之中,情况将有明显的改观。按照三分法,仁性和智性在道德存有中发挥着不同的作用。仁性负责创生存有,这种创生是通过呈现实现的,而这种呈现的思维方式并非如牟宗三所说是康德意义的智的直觉。智性负责认知,这一认知既可以通过内识证明为什么说道德存有是通过仁性呈现实现的,仁性为什么可以这种意义的呈现,又可以通过外识证明外部对象的存在,从而对道德存有问题加以清楚的阐发。
关键词:
牟宗三; 仁性; 智性; 道德存有; 儒家生生伦理学
收稿日期:
2019-06-19
中图分类号:
B261;B82-0
文献标识码:
A
文章编号:
1672-4283(2020)01-0083-09
基金项目:
教育部哲学社会科学研究后期资助重大项目“儒家生生伦理学研究”(16JHQ001)
Doi:
Different Roles of Renxing and Zhixing in Moral Ontology
YANG Zebo
(School of Philosophy, Fudan University, Shanghai 200433)
Abstract:
Moral ontology is a theory of cardinal significance in Confucianism, and it is also the topic that Mou Zongsan paid special attention to throughout his life after he was taught by Xiong Shili. However, due to the limitations of perceptualrational dichotomy, Mou Zong san’s elucidation still presents some weak points.If the thought is put into the framework of the trichotomy of zhixing, renxing and yuxing from Shengsheng Ethics of Confucianism, the situation will be significantly changed. According to the trichotomy, renxing (benevolence) and zhixing (intelligence) play different roles in in moral ontology. Renxing is responsible for the creation of moral ontology which is achieved through presentation; however, its way of thinking is not Mou Zongsan’s unique interpretation of Kant’s concept of intellectual intuition. Zhixing is responsible for cognition, and the cognition can not only explain why moral ontology is realized by the presentation of renxing through inner knowledge, but also prove the existence of external objects through outer knowledge, thus explicating the problem of moral ontology clearly.
KeyWords:
Mou Zongsan; renxing; zhixing; moral ontology; Shengsheng Ethics of Confucianism