哲学社会科学版
陕西师范大学学报(哲学社会科学版)
辩证唯物主义与历史认识研究
诠释的多样性与历史比较的统一性
PDF下载 ()
王 成 军
(陕西师范大学 历史文化学院, 陕西 西安 710119)
王成军,男,陕西西安人,历史学博士,陕西师范大学历史文化学院教授,博士研究生导师。
摘要:
不管是哲学诠释学的视域融合论,还是历史比较观,都以同与异的相对立为前提,又以同与异的相统一为认识目的。这种统一性不仅具有多样性特征,还带有普遍性的内在发展的趋向和要求,通过比较和不断地诠释来展示普遍联系,以形成更为广泛和深入的认识或理解,最终达到对历史规律的认识。但哲学诠释学的视域融合观念,只是强调了诠释的历史性和多样性,并没有揭示出诠释的普遍统一性,更没有从这种普遍统一性中总结出规律性。究其根本原因,在于它没能从辩证唯物主义的角度来看待来诠释世界的现象,没能真正地从社会历史的实践角度深化和发展不同视域相融合的成果。将视域融合论和历史比较进行比较研究,不仅可以发现视域融合观念所包含的某些历史进步性,也可以明显地发现其诠释的历史局限性,从而为历史比较提供重要的理论借鉴,对探索和丰富历史比较的理论和方法也具有重要意义。
关键词:
视域融合; 历史比较; 辩证唯物主义; 哲学诠释学; 伽达默尔
收稿日期:
2019-10-07
中图分类号:
B089.2;B027
文献标识码:
A
文章编号:
1672-4283(2020)01-0071-12
基金项目:
国家社会科学基金重点项目“视域融合与中西史学比较的关联与融通”(17ASS001)
Doi:
Diversity of Philosophical Hermeneutics and Universality of Historical Comparison
WANG Chengjun
(School of History and Civilization, Shaanxi Normal University,Xi’an 710119, Shaanxi)
Abstract:
Both the theory of horizonfusion in philosophical hermeneutics and the view of historical comparison are premised on the opposition between commonness and difference, and the unity between commonness and difference is the objective of cognition. Not only does this unity contain by diversity, but it also contains universality as trends and selfrequirements on its way of development, which is to demonstrate the universal connections via comparisons and constant interpretations, the purpose of which is to form a more extensive and indepth cognition and understanding, and the result of which is to achieve an understanding of historical laws. Merely stressing the historicity and diversity of interpretation, the horizonfusion theory fails to reveal the universal connections of interpretation, let alone summarize the laws in the universal connections. The fundamental reason lies in its failure to view and interpret the world from the perspective of dialectical materialism, and its failure to deepen and develop the outcomes of fusion from the perspective of authentic social and historical practice. Therefore, the integration of the theories of horizonfusion and historical comparison helps to find not only the progress contained in the conception of horizonfusion, but also the historical limitations of interpretation, thus to provide important theoretical references to historical comparison.Hence, it is of great significance to integrate the theories of horizonfusion and historical comparison under the guidance of dialectical materialism in terms of the further development of historical comparison.
KeyWords:
horizonfusion; historical comparison integration; dialectical materialism; hermeneutics; HansGeorg Gadamer