哲学社会科学版
陕西师范大学学报(哲学社会科学版)
黑格尔与启蒙研究
青年黑格尔与启蒙
PDF下载 ()
王 兴 赛
(中山大学 哲学系, 广东 广州 510275)
王兴赛,男,山东菏泽人,哲学博士,中山大学马克思主义哲学与中国现代化研究所暨哲学系博士后科研流动站研究人员。
摘要:
根据“Aufklrung”及相关词在黑格尔早期(1785—1800)作品中出现的情况可知,启蒙运动构成黑格尔的教育背景,青年黑格尔首先像门德尔松和康德一样肯定启蒙或启蒙运动在科学、艺术、宗教、历史和政治等方面的重要性,同时黑格尔在这段时期对启蒙运动的批判可分为两个阶段: 一是青年黑格尔在道德宗教层面批判启蒙理智不能真正推动人们的道德和宗教情感;二是青年黑格尔在历史性、多样性和现实性层面批判启蒙概念的抽象性和同质性。门德尔松、康德与青年黑格尔对启蒙运动的态度有同有异, 且都涉及如何处理理论与实践的关系问题。康德和门德尔松的划界方案与黑格尔的和解方案都存在问题,或许更为可取的做法是在划界基础上对理论问题采取理论思维,对实践问题采取实践思维。
关键词:
德国哲学; 黑格尔; 启蒙运动; 道德宗教; 康德; 门德尔松
收稿日期:
2019-07-02
中图分类号:
B516.35
文献标识码:
A
文章编号:
1672-4283(2019)06-0128-11
基金项目:
中国博士后科学基金第63批面上资助“青年黑格尔与青年马克思政治哲学思想比较研究”(2018M633263); 教育部人文社会科学重点研究基地重大项目“马克思主义实践哲学与全球化时代的人类理想”(16JJD710015); 中山大学高校基本科研业务费青年教师培育项目“青年黑格尔与青年马克思现代性思想比较研究”(17WKPY49)
Doi:
Young Hegel and the Enlightenment
WANG Xingsai
(Department of Philosophy, Sun Yatsen University, Guangzhou 510275, Guangdong)
Abstract:
By searching for “Aufklrung” and its derivatives in the young Hegel’s works (1785—1800), we can find that firstly, the Enlightenment is the background to Hegel’s education, and secondly, like Mendelssohn and Kant, he highly values the important role of the Enlightenment in science, art, religion, history and politics, and thirdly, Hegel’s critique of the Enlightenment during this period can be divided into two stages. In the first stage, when talking about religion and morality, Hegel points out that the Enlightenment and Understanding cannot really promote people’s moral and religious feelings. In the second stage, by emphasizing history, diversity and reality, Hegel criticizes the abstraction and homogeneity of the Enlightenment. Mendelssohn, Kant and the young Hegel not only have common attitudes towards the Enlightenment, they also have different views, which involve the relationship between theory and practice. Both Mendelssohn and Kant’s solution of delimitation between theory and practice and Hegel's solution of reconciliation is problematic. It is preferable that theory namely that thinking should be put in its proper place of cognizing principles and praxis, namely that thinking should be put in its proper place of dealing with practice,should be thought of thus.
KeyWords:
German Philosophy; Hegel; the Enlightenment; morality religion; Kant; Mendelssohn