哲学社会科学版
陕西师范大学学报(哲学社会科学版)
学术评论与争鸣
吴简所见的“吏户”及吏户问题研究
PDF下载 ()
孟 彦 弘
(中国历史研究院 古代史研究所, 北京 102008)
孟彦弘,男,山西襄垣人,历史学博士,中国历史研究院古代史研究所研究员。
摘要:
吴简所反映的吏及吏役,是以户为单位服役,说明了其时“吏户” 已经出现。这与户籍编制的方式、服吏役者的地位高低无关。《评长沙走马楼吴简“吏民”问题研究及学术乱象》所作的相关评论并不中肯,且夹杂了大量非学术内容。学术评论应当一本学术立场,恪守学术规范,将评论内容严格限定在学术范围内。
关键词:
吴简; 吏户; 吴简研究; 学术评论; 学术规范
收稿日期:
2018-06-15
中图分类号:
K239
文献标识码:
A
文章编号:
1672-4283(2019)02-0012-11
基金项目:
Doi:
Study About Lihu (吏户) From Wujian (吴简) and Related Lihu Research
MENG Yanhong
(Ancient History Institute, History Academy of China, Beijing 102008)
Abstract:
Wujian shows that Li (吏) and Lihu is based on Hu (户) as an unit for service. This demonstrates the beginning of Lihu. Lihu has no relation with the arrangement of registration system and the status of the labor for service. The findings from Mr. Li Wencai’s article,“Comment on the Study of“Limin”(吏民) from the Wu Bamboo Slips at Zoumalou (走马楼吴简)”,is not quite correct, and it has a lot of nonprofessional discussion. Professional discussion should be based on the academic perspective, follow the strict rules of the profession, and restrict the professional spectrum.K
KeyWords:
Wujian;Lihu; Wujian study; professional discussion; professional criterion