哲学社会科学版
陕西师范大学学报(哲学社会科学版)
20世纪史学研究
缪凤林的通史编纂风格
PDF下载 ()
刘 永 祥
(中国海洋大学 社会科学部, 山东 青岛 266100)
刘永祥,男,山东寿光市人,历史学博士,中国海洋大学社会科学部讲师。
摘要:
缪凤林是继梁启超之后较早在理论和实践上探索中国通史编纂并取得显著成就的历史家和理论家。他通过编纂《中国通史纲要》和《中国通史要略》,在编纂理论、形式、史书体裁等多方面进行了大胆创新进而成为20世纪三四十年代中国通史编纂新高潮的典型代表之一。他旨在以通史编纂激扬民族精神,特别重视“关于表现民族自力之纪录”,将中华民族的形成和发展作为历史叙述的主线来凸显中华民族的整体性与独特性。他一方面从史学内涵及功能等方面阐述“通史所系者巨”,另一方面通过辨析史学的主客观关系来说明通史编纂中“笔削”的必要性和复杂性并为之设定主要标准。此外,他还尝试着将中国传统的史书体裁纪事本末体和典志体与西方的章节体相结合,在此基础上创造出新综合体,不仅展现了历史演进的趋势,而且还涵纳了丰富的社会内容,成为中西合璧的典范之作。
关键词:
缪凤林; 民族主义; 通史编纂; 《中国通史纲要》; 新综合体
收稿日期:
2015-04-20
中图分类号:
K062
文献标识码:
A
文章编号:
1672-4283(2015)04-0029-08
基金项目:
国家社会科学基金重点项目(09AZS001);国家社会科学基金青年项目(14CZS001)
Doi:
Miao Fenglin’s Style in Compiling Chinese General History
LIU Yongxiang
(Department of Social Sciences, Ocean University of China, Qingdao 266100, Shandong)
Abstract:
Miao Fenglin was an eminent historian and theorist who explored the compilation of Chinese general history theoretically and practically in relatively early days and made prominent accomplishments after Liang Qichao. By compiling The Outline of Chinese General History and The Summary of Chinese General History, he courageously innovated in compiling theory, forms and modes of historical works, which established him as one of the typical representatives in the new upsurge of compiling Chinese general history in the 1930s and 1940s. He intended to inspire the spirit of the Chinese nation by compiling general history, paying special attention to “recording the performance of national own strength” taking the shaping and growth of the Chinese nation as the mainline of historical narration to magnify the integrity and individuality of the nation. On the one hand, he expounded “the importance of general history” in terms of implications and functions of history, and on the other, he explained the necessity and complexity of “alternative tradeoff” and set up the key standards for it by discriminatively analyzing the subjective and objective relationship in history studies. Based on this, he managed to create a new complex as a model of combination of Chinese and western historiographies, which not only presented the tendency of historical evolution but also included rich social contents.
KeyWords:
Miao Fenglin; nationalism; compilation of Chinese general history; The Outline General Chinese History; a new complex mode